Our site uses cookies necessary for its proper functioning. To improve your experience, other cookies may be used: you can choose to disable them. This can be changed at any time via the Cookies link at the bottom of the page.


The “notched cylindrical bars under constant load test” (NCBT) for assessing the resistance to crack initiation of PE100 and PE100 RC: determination of the initiation time

 

Papers

Plastic Pipes Conference Association # 2016 Berlin

Dominique GUEUGNAUT, Adil BOUJLAL, Aymeric LOPITAUX, Romuald BOUAFFRE

A specific methodology has been designed by ENGIE’ R&T Division to allow an accurate determination of the initiation (incubation) time of the NCBT data. This methodology is based on two different data processing procedures. The first data processing proceeds from searching the minimum of the second derivative of both a 3rd order and a 6th order polynomial fitting of the curve. Such approach is not well suited to very flat curves or to unsteady curves on the one hand, and needs to define a low limit of the strain for data processing, in order not to emphasize the curvature at the beginning of the test on the other hand. The second data processing proceeds from searching the minimum of the strain rate all along the test. Such an approach is pertinent and does not require any low strain limit to process the data. Moreover, processing the data in real time allows one to stop the test a short time after the minimum strain rate has been detected. This preferred procedure gives way to an accurate determination of the initiation (incubation) time, hence reducing drastically the NCB Test duration for a quick evaluation of a PE grade.

In the last five years some new and innovative tests have been designed to assess for Slow Crack Growth (SCG) behavior of PE100 and PE100 RC with the objective of reducing drastically the test time duration. Three tests have been focused on by the WG20 of the ISO TC138-SC5 committee. These tests are the Strain Hardening Test (SHT), the Cyclic Crack Round Bar Test (CCRBT) and the Notched Cylindrical Bars under constant load Test (NCBT). These three tests allow to assess for SCG resistance of PE100 and PE100 RC in a reasonable test duration less than 1,000h with the major advantage to avoid the utilization of any surfactant suspected of modifying the SCG process. The two former tests were the subject of an intensive evaluation through round robin tests managed by the WG20 and finally became ISO standards in 2015. The NCBT was first evaluated in 2013on PE100 and PE100 RC by ENGIE’R&T Division and then proposed to the WG20. The promising results presented during the Plastic Pipes XVII opened the way to the standardization process and to a CD document in 2015. One of the advantages of the NCBT is the possibility to detect in a very accurate way the crack initiation (or incubation) time and thus to shorten the test time duration in a very effective proportion. The crack initiation time corresponds to the “trigger” for crack to progess and can be modelled by means of an elasto-visco-plastic theoretical approach as presented formerly as, for instance, during the Plastic Pipes XVI. A first method was designed by R&T Division in order to detect the initiation time. This method, based on the fitting of the NCBT curve by means of polynomial laws, required approximately 2/3 of the up-to-failure curve and was very sensitive to the flatness of the curve. In order to avoid this, a refined method is proposed which focuses on the strain rate. The method was successfully applied on four PE100 and five PE100 RC. Then the “live” detection of the minimum strain rate allows a very accurate determination of the crack initiation time and a drastic test time reduction for a quick evaluation of a PE grade.Furthermore, the true stress applied to the specimen can be calculated – for comparison purposes with the target one -once the initiation time has been determined by provoking the failure of the material in liquid nitrogen.

Related keywords : Polyethylene; PE; Notched Cylindrical Bars under constant load Test (NCBT), Crack Initiation (Incubation) Time, Slow Crack Growth, PE100 RC, ISO TC138-SC5-WG20.
Please note that the whole article content is available on PPCA website only :

Related papers

2023 Lake Buena Vista : A NEW CONCEPT FOR TESTING OF NEW GENERATION OF THERMOPLASTIC STORMWATER RETENTION TANKS

Author(s) : Shad Sargand, Issam Khoury, John Kurdziel

One solution in development for managing runoff water is the buried stormwater drainage retention tank or “crate”. The crate is typically a rectangular box structure made of thermoplastic components (flat panels and columns) assembled in a modular form. The function of the top panel is to transfer the load to the...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : A NEW GENERATION OF HIGH PERFORMANCE BIAXIALLY ORIENTED POLYETHYLENE AND POLYPROPYLENE PRESSURE PIPES – AN UPDATE

Author(s) : Ajay Taraiya, Peter Degenhart, Mark Boerakker

In PPXX, a technology was presented for the first time that could bi-axially orient polyolefin pipes. With this technology, it is possible to prepare pipes that have a performance far beyond the standard ones. One approach to achieving this performance is via a continuous in-line process. To optimize the in-line...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : ALTERNATIVE SLOW CRACK GROWTH TEST FOR THE HDPE CONDUIT INDUSTRY: CORRELATION BETWEEN ESCR AND NCLS

Author(s) : Kevin Copher, Patrick Vibien

High Density Polyethylene (HDPE) conduit is a durable product designed to protect cables for multiple generations buried underground or encased in concrete. Conduit is subject to coiling stresses, installation stresses and in-service stresses, such as those generated from installed curvature, soil loading, or rock...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : AN INVESTIGATION OF THE EFFECT OF BACKFILL TYPE ON THE PERFORMANCE OF LARGE DIAMETER POLYOLEFIN PIPE UNDER HIGHWAY LOADINGS AT MINIMUM COVER

Author(s) : Joe Babcanec, P.E., Issam Khoury, Ph.D, P.E., Shad Sargand,

The use of corrugated HDPE and PP pipe for gravity flow storm sewers is a growing trend throughout the United States. Many of these drainage pipes are buried in shallow cover conditions under roads with heavy traffic. It is well established that thermoplastic pipe installations under shallow cover respond differently...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : DESIGN METHODS AND ACTUAL PERFORMANCE OF LARGE DIAMETER STRUCTURED WALL PIPES

Author(s) : Anders Andtbacka, Peter Sejersen

In March 1999, a project report on the performance of buried Thermoplastics pipes was published by TEPPFA /1/. In the report, deflection and strain data on buried pipes were analyzed and compared with calculation results from several well-known static calculation models in use in Europe. Pipes were installed to...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : DEVELOPMENT OF A NEW QUALITY CONTROL TEST METHOD TO ASSESS THE STRESS CRACK RESISTANCE OF HDPE

Author(s) : Dr. Michael Pluimer, Sara Stone

The Notched Constant Ligament Stress test (NCLS test, ASTM F2136)[1] is a test method that measures the slow crack growth in High Density Polyethylene. The NCLS test requires a notch on all test specimens to act as a stress concentration at that point so crack propagation can be easily predicted and studied. In...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : DEVELOPMENT OF AN ACCELERATED POINT LOAD TEST FOR THE EVALUATION OF PIPES MADE OF PE 100-RC

Author(s) : Ernst van der Stok, Mirko Wenzel, Thomas Kratochvilla, Kurt Engelsing, Werner Weßing, Britta Gerets

It has not been possible to derive an accelerated procedure for the Point Load Test (PLT) as a pipe test before now. Further research and testing were therefore needed to establish appropriate requirements for standards including EN 1555-1 to rule out uncertainty in the market. The PLT is a central product test for...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : DEVELOPMENT OF HYDRO-AXIAL TENSION METHOD FOR WHOLE PIPE TENSILE TEST

Author(s) : Sunwoong Choi, Robert Stakenborghs , Pyeongan Lee, Byoungho Choi

This work developed a hydro-axial tension (HAT) test as a whole pipe axial tensile test and applied to evaluate the polyethylene (PE) pipe and fusion joints containing various flaws. HAT test was designed to utilize hydrostatic pressure to cause axial tension in pipes. The experimental and numerical analysis was...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : DIFFERENT THERMO-OXIDATIVE TESTS IN COMPARISON FOR ONE INDUSTRIAL PE PIPE COMPOUND

Author(s) : Norbert Jansen

A practical requirement of temperature resistance of minimum 50 years at 70°C was established for the extra high voltage (EHV) corridor projects in Germany. Experts have debated what tests are best suited to prove the suitability of a pipe resin for cable protection pipes which may be installed hastily and under...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : EFFECT OF NOTCH RADIUS ON NOTCHED PIPE FAILURE TIME

Author(s) : Aisha Khaleel, Suleyman Deveci, Sulistiyanto Nugroho, Fatima AlHameli

The use of polyethylene pipes in transportation networks of pressurized water and gas have shown superb performance over the history. High density, high-molecular-weight, and bi-modal polyethylene materials, known as PE80, PE100 and PE100RC, have successfully served the market for many years in standard applications....

2023 Lake Buena Vista : EFFECT OF POLYPROPYLENE (PP) POST-CONSUMER RECYCLATE ON THE SLOW CRACK GROWTH RESISTANCE OF A VIRGIN PP PIPE MATERIAL

Author(s) : Jessica Hinczica, Mario Messiha, Florian Arbeiter, Gerald Pinter

In Europe, only 1.8 million tons of recycled material is processed in new products within the building and construction sector [1]. Recyclates and blends of recyclates with virgin materials are already used for different products in the plastic pipe industry, such as cable trays, or storm water management...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : EFFECTS OF POLYMER DESIGN PARAMETERS ON THE SLOW CRACK GROWTH RESISTANCE BASED ON CRACKED ROUND BAR

Author(s) : Jiyong Park, JaeHyuck Han, YoungGu Kim, Eunjin Park

This study investigates the influence of various parameters on polymer design to determine the slow crack growth. HDPE(High Density Polyethylene) materials with different molecular weight distribution and comonomer content for PE100-RC pipe were investigated with cracked round bar test. The cracked round bar test...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : ENHANCING RECYCLED MATERIALS THROUGH COMPATIBILIZATION TECHNOLOGIES TO ENABLE HIGH PERFORMANCE

Author(s) : Jie Wu, Yushan Hu, Todd Hogan

Recycling of plastic materials is key to demonstrating that these high value materials are much more than a waste stream and a key component of a sustainable future. The plastic pipe market effectively utilizes in-plant recycle systems where standards and codes allow processors to recapture the value of these...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : ESTABLISHING REQUIREMENTS FOR RECYCLED HDPE IN HDPE CONDUIT

Author(s) : Michael Pluimer, Christian Herrild, Patrick Vibien

With enhanced interest in a circular economy and the potential use of recycled HDPE within HDPE conduit, a research project was undertaken to investigate the necessary technical requirements when using recycled HDPE. High Density Polyethylene (HDPE) conduit is a durable product designed to protect cables...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : FIELD AND FEM PERFORMANCE OF AGRICULTURAL MAINS

Author(s) : Kevin White, Shad Sargand

The current standard of practice for the installation of agricultural mains is in accordance with ASTM F449, Standard Practice for Subsurface Installation of Corrugated Polyethylene Pipe for Agricultural Drainage or Water Table Control. ASTM F449 has several limitations. Currently, the allowable maximum height of...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : FROM FISHING NETS TO PLASTIC PIPES: NEW CHALLENGES FOR RECYCLED POLYETHYLENE FLOWS IN A CIRCULAR ECONOMY

Author(s) : Rafael A. García-Muñoz, Rafael Juan, Mónica de la Cruz, Beatriz Paredes, Carlos Domínguez

Plastics are widely used in various industries, resulting in the generation of significant amounts of plastic waste, which causes environmental and economic problems. Although mechanical recycling is the most commonly employed technology, the resulting recyclates often suffer from degradation and contamination. This...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : FUSION TEST PROGRAM ON POLYAMIDE PIPING SYSTEMS FOR DISTRIBUTION NETWORKS UP TO 16 BAR

Author(s) : Carine Lacroix, Philippe Louvel, Danielle Mark, Dominique Gueugnaut

A test program was carried out on two Polyamide resins, Polyamide 11 (PA11) and Polyamide 12 (PA12), both certified for gas networks. Polyamide’s advantage lies in its implementation, similar to that of polyethylene, and its properties allowing it to operate at up to 18 bar for gas, all other conditions being equal....

2023 Lake Buena Vista : HOW TO CONTROL CRACKS IN PIPES TO GUARANTEE A SAFE OPERATION

Author(s) : Gerald Pinter, Lukas Travnicek, Johannes Wiener, Jan Poduska, Florian Arbeiter, Pavel Hutar

Crack initiation and subsequent crack growth are known to be the key factors which determine the final lifetime of a polymeric pipe. Subsequently, exact knowledge regarding the crack growth behavior is a key issue to guarantee safe operation. Furthermore, novel concepts are needed to satisfy increasing demands, for...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : INFLUENCING FACTORS OF CRACKED ROUND BAR TEST

Author(s) : Yanlei Hu, Jin Sun

Slow crack growth is the main reason for brittle failure of polyethylene pipes. At present, the traditional slow crack growth test generally has many problems, such as too long test time, using chemical reagents that pollute the environment, poor reproducibility, etc., which limit the accurate evaluation of the slow...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : INNOVATING FOR SUSTAINABILITY ENHANCEMENTS IN POLYETHYLENE BASED MICROIRRIGATION PRODUCTS

Author(s) : Rachel Anderson, Rujul Mehta, Alex Stolarz, Todd Hogan, Stephanie Whited, Joel Wieliczko

Growing worldwide demand for sustainably made irrigation systems has driven the creation of new resins for longer-lasting, more durable, recycle friendly, and cost-effective pipe that can better tolerate extreme conditions year after year. Microirrigation systems deliver vital water and nutrients where they’re needed...

Members of the Association

BOREALISBOROUGEFormosa Plastics CorporationHanwha TotalEnergiesINEOS O&PIRPCKorea Petrochemical IND. Co., LTD (KPIC)LyondellBasellORLEN UnipetrolPetroChina Dushanzi Petrochemical CompanyPRIME POLYMERSABICSCG Chemicals & Thai PolyethyleneSinopecTASNEE