Our site uses cookies necessary for its proper functioning. To improve your experience, other cookies may be used: you can choose to disable them. This can be changed at any time via the Cookies link at the bottom of the page.


Aging mechanism of polyethylene pipe material in chlorine dioxide and hypochlorite solution

 

Papers

Plastic Pipes Conference Association # 2018 Las-Vegas

Márton Bredács, Andreas Frank, Amaia Bastero, Alex Stolarz, Gerald Pinter

Accelerated aging experiments by the immersion of a commercial polyethylene (PE) pipe grade in 10 ppm of chlorine dioxide (ClO2) and in 100 ppm of hypochlorite (HOCl) solution at 60 °C were performed. An additional immersion test was conducted in 1 ppm of ClO2 at 40 °C. The exposure parameters were continuously controlled especially the disinfectant concentration during the aging of 1 mm thick tensile specimens. Analysis techniques such as SEM, tensile test, FTIR and DSC-OOT, revealed significant differences in the aging mechanism caused by the two disinfectants. On the one hand, the presence of ClO2 induced an apparent parallel material embrittlement with the consumption of active stabilizers, displaying surface cracks and a few hundred microns thick degraded surface layer. On the other hand, the results of HOCl exposure indicate an accelerated auto-oxidative degradation, displaying an etched-like, rough surface characteristic with numerous cavities, without the appearance of distinct surface cracks and degraded layer. 

Chlorine dioxide (ClO2) and hypochlorite (HOCl) are the most used oxidizing agents for secondary drinking water disinfection due to their high effectivity against pathogenic microorganisms. Considering the strong oxidative nature of these disinfectants, accelerated antioxidant consumption and material degradation can be expected in the affected pipe surface layer. The presence of chlorine-based oxidizing agents will shorten the crack initiation time and lead to premature pipe failure. 

To accurately study the effect of ClO2 and HOCl on polyethylene (PE) pipes materials, during laboratory aging stable exposure parameters are essential to generate reliable and reproducible data. Unfortunately, accelerated experiments with constant concentration are quite challenging in laboratory scale due to the fast reaction with organic and inorganic compounds as well as the considerable thermal decomposition of both disinfectants. To overcome this obstacle, an exposure device was developed at PCCL, which allows stable and well-controlled aging experiments in ClO2 and HOCl solutions.

The objective of this work is to provide further insight into the relevant degradation process of PE in chlorinated media. Tensile specimens with a thickness of 1 mm were periodically removed after immersion in 10 ppm of ClO2, 100 ppm of HOCl solution at 60°C and in 1 ppm of ClO2 at 40°C. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images showed surface cracks and a few hundred micron thick embrittled material layer due to immersion in ClO2, while exposure to HOCl resulted in an etched like surface without micro-cracks and degraded surface layer. Based on Oxidation Onset Temperature (OOT), tensile tests and IR-spectroscopy (FTIR) analyses, distinct aging processes were observed for each disinfectant. In case of ClO2, the results indicate that the oxidizing agent attacks simultaneously the polymer and the antioxidant molecules. Exposure to HOCl led to material embrittlement only after the complete loss of active antioxidants. Profound knowledge of the dominating aging mechanisms is essential to develop PE pipe materials and antioxidant packages with increased performance in contact with chlorinated water. 

Related keywords : Polyethylene pipes, Aging mechanism, Chlorine dioxide, Hypochlorite solution.
Please note that the whole article content is available on PPCA website only :

Related papers

2023 Lake Buena Vista : 2.7 METERS AND GROWING

Author(s) : Dr. Henning Stieglitz

Urbanization and the increasing effects of climate change have meant the supply of fresh water and the disposal of wastewater, have become increasingly important in recent years. It is foreseeable that this demand will continue and intensify. In this context, plastic pipe plays a major role due to its unique...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : A NEW GENERATION OF HIGH PERFORMANCE BIAXIALLY ORIENTED POLYETHYLENE AND POLYPROPYLENE PRESSURE PIPES – AN UPDATE

Author(s) : Ajay Taraiya, Peter Degenhart, Mark Boerakker

In PPXX, a technology was presented for the first time that could bi-axially orient polyolefin pipes. With this technology, it is possible to prepare pipes that have a performance far beyond the standard ones. One approach to achieving this performance is via a continuous in-line process. To optimize the in-line...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : AN INVESTIGATION OF THE EFFECT OF BACKFILL TYPE ON THE PERFORMANCE OF LARGE DIAMETER POLYOLEFIN PIPE UNDER HIGHWAY LOADINGS AT MINIMUM COVER

Author(s) : Joe Babcanec, P.E., Issam Khoury, Ph.D, P.E., Shad Sargand,

The use of corrugated HDPE and PP pipe for gravity flow storm sewers is a growing trend throughout the United States. Many of these drainage pipes are buried in shallow cover conditions under roads with heavy traffic. It is well established that thermoplastic pipe installations under shallow cover respond differently...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : DESIGN METHODS AND ACTUAL PERFORMANCE OF LARGE DIAMETER STRUCTURED WALL PIPES

Author(s) : Anders Andtbacka, Peter Sejersen

In March 1999, a project report on the performance of buried Thermoplastics pipes was published by TEPPFA /1/. In the report, deflection and strain data on buried pipes were analyzed and compared with calculation results from several well-known static calculation models in use in Europe. Pipes were installed to...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : DEVELOPMENT OF A NEW QUALITY CONTROL TEST METHOD TO ASSESS THE STRESS CRACK RESISTANCE OF HDPE

Author(s) : Dr. Michael Pluimer, Sara Stone

The Notched Constant Ligament Stress test (NCLS test, ASTM F2136)[1] is a test method that measures the slow crack growth in High Density Polyethylene. The NCLS test requires a notch on all test specimens to act as a stress concentration at that point so crack propagation can be easily predicted and studied. In...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : DEVELOPMENT OF HYDRO-AXIAL TENSION METHOD FOR WHOLE PIPE TENSILE TEST

Author(s) : Sunwoong Choi, Robert Stakenborghs , Pyeongan Lee, Byoungho Choi

This work developed a hydro-axial tension (HAT) test as a whole pipe axial tensile test and applied to evaluate the polyethylene (PE) pipe and fusion joints containing various flaws. HAT test was designed to utilize hydrostatic pressure to cause axial tension in pipes. The experimental and numerical analysis was...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : ENHANCING RECYCLED MATERIALS THROUGH COMPATIBILIZATION TECHNOLOGIES TO ENABLE HIGH PERFORMANCE

Author(s) : Jie Wu, Yushan Hu, Todd Hogan

Recycling of plastic materials is key to demonstrating that these high value materials are much more than a waste stream and a key component of a sustainable future. The plastic pipe market effectively utilizes in-plant recycle systems where standards and codes allow processors to recapture the value of these...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : FIELD AND FEM PERFORMANCE OF AGRICULTURAL MAINS

Author(s) : Kevin White, Shad Sargand

The current standard of practice for the installation of agricultural mains is in accordance with ASTM F449, Standard Practice for Subsurface Installation of Corrugated Polyethylene Pipe for Agricultural Drainage or Water Table Control. ASTM F449 has several limitations. Currently, the allowable maximum height of...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : FROM FISHING NETS TO PLASTIC PIPES: NEW CHALLENGES FOR RECYCLED POLYETHYLENE FLOWS IN A CIRCULAR ECONOMY

Author(s) : Rafael A. García-Muñoz, Rafael Juan, Mónica de la Cruz, Beatriz Paredes, Carlos Domínguez

Plastics are widely used in various industries, resulting in the generation of significant amounts of plastic waste, which causes environmental and economic problems. Although mechanical recycling is the most commonly employed technology, the resulting recyclates often suffer from degradation and contamination. This...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : HOW AN INDUSTRY LEAD PVC PLASTIC PIPES RECYCLING SCHEME CAN CHANGE PERCEPTIONS, EDUCATE, AND PROVIDE VALUABLE INSIGHTS FOR A MORE SUSTAINABLE SOLUTION

Author(s) : Cindy Bray

For over two decades, the plastics pipe industry in Australia has aimed to recycle the maximum amount of usable plastic pipe and other suitable materials into new plastic pipes through programs such as take-back schemes and providing collection facilities on manufacturing sites. In Australia long-term sustainability...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : HOW PVC PIPES CAN CONTRIBUTE TO FOOD SAFETY IN THE WORLD’S MEGA-CITIES

Author(s) : Tobias Johnsen, Ole Grøndahl Hansen

With a growing global population that will primarily settle in urban areas, more and more agricultural land will be converted into dwellings, roads etc. As the demand for food in 2050 will be 60% greater than today, a conflict between Sustainable Development Goals 2 (Zero Hunger) and 11 (Sustainable Cities and...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : HOW TO STRENGTHEN THE DEVELOPMENT OF CHINA’S PLASTIC PIPE INDUSTRY IN THE NEW MARKET ENVIRONMENT

Author(s) : Zhanjie Wang, Jing Guo, Lin Wang

In the past two years, the Chinese plastic pipe industry has faced a complex and changeable development situation. The domestic economy has faced the pressure of demand shrinkage, supply impact, and expected weakness, and the market has changed greatly. The impact of the Covid-19 and the influence of many unfavorable...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : IMPROVING MECHANICAL SORTING OF POST-CONSUMER PLASTIC WASTE TO ACHIEVE CIRCULAR USE OF PLASTIC PIPES

Author(s) : Márton Bredács, Jutta Geier, Mario Messiha, Gernot Oreski, Gerald Koinig, Raphael Horvath, Szilveszter Gergely, Gerald Pinter

In 2020, the global plastics production was 367 million tons. In Europe 20 % was used in the building and construction sector to manufacture in significant proportion polyethylene (PE) and polypropylene (PP) pipes [1]. To increase the current 30 % recycling rate, it is crucial to improve the quality of recyclates and...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : INFLUENCING FACTORS OF CRACKED ROUND BAR TEST

Author(s) : Yanlei Hu, Jin Sun

Slow crack growth is the main reason for brittle failure of polyethylene pipes. At present, the traditional slow crack growth test generally has many problems, such as too long test time, using chemical reagents that pollute the environment, poor reproducibility, etc., which limit the accurate evaluation of the slow...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : INNOVATING FOR SUSTAINABILITY ENHANCEMENTS IN POLYETHYLENE BASED MICROIRRIGATION PRODUCTS

Author(s) : Rachel Anderson, Rujul Mehta, Alex Stolarz, Todd Hogan, Stephanie Whited, Joel Wieliczko

Growing worldwide demand for sustainably made irrigation systems has driven the creation of new resins for longer-lasting, more durable, recycle friendly, and cost-effective pipe that can better tolerate extreme conditions year after year. Microirrigation systems deliver vital water and nutrients where they’re needed...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : LIFECYCLE COST BENEFITS OF PVC-U PIPES IN EUROPE

Author(s) : A. Marangoni

The competitiveness of plastic pipes vs. non plastic pipes for water and sewer networks relies on both a superior performance to cost ratio and environmental benefits that can be offered to the utility industry, across the whole lifecycle of these networks. In order to help the European pipe network owners in...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : MAKING THE ACCELERATED NOTCH PIPE TEST (ANPT) FUTURE-PROOF

Author(s) : Ernst van der Stok, Nadia Luijsterburg-Vleugels

The latest generation of polyethylene grades (PE 100-RC and PE 4710 PLUS) have an increased resistance to slow crack growth. Such cracks can be initiated by either a scratch during installation or a rock indentation during use. The Accelerated Notch Pipe Test (ANPT) was standardized in ISO 13479 in 2022 to allow the...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : MEETING THE EUROPEAN NORDIC QUALITY REQUIREMENTS FOR PVC PIPES WITH RECYCLED MATERIAL

Author(s) : Tobias Johnsen

To ensure the highest possible quality of plastic pipes for the Nordic market, the Nordic Poly Mark currently only allows virgin material or own reprocessed material. In order to accelerate the circular plastic pipe economy in the Nordics, a partnership between a PVC pipe waste collection system, a PVC pipe producer...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : NEW CYCLIC METHOD FOR PVC FORCE MAINS

Author(s) : Jay Parvez, Richard Nichols

All thermoplastic and thermoset pipes must consider the impacts of cyclic loading on overall performance. Since its first use, PVC pipes have been tested for its resilience to such loading. As testing evolved over time, the method to determine cyclic capacity for gasketed PVC pipes has improved. Previously, the...

2023 Lake Buena Vista : PE100 MATERIAL SUPPORTS WORLD’S LARGEST WASTEWATER TREATMENT PLANT – BAHR EL BAQAR, EGYPT

Author(s) : Peter Youssef, Sultan Alkendi, Hussein Basha

Bahr El-Baqar Water Treatment Plant, produces 2 billion m3 per year, introduces a sustainable solution for environmental pollution recovery and irrigation water source (via recycling the water of Bahr El- Baqar drain); whereas it protects the environment and generates water to support the cultivation of 4000 km2 in...

Members of the Association

BOREALISBOROUGEFormosa Plastics CorporationHanwha TotalEnergiesINEOS O&PIRPCKorea Petrochemical IND. Co., LTD (KPIC)LyondellBasellORLEN UnipetrolPetroChina Dushanzi Petrochemical CompanyPRIME POLYMERSABICSCG Chemicals & Thai PolyethyleneSinopecTASNEE